LIVE REPORTING: Council in High Court Bid to Ban City Flag Displays

Birmingham City Council has launched High Court proceedings against "Raise the Colours" figures to secure an emergency injunction against flag displays.
🔴 LIVE REPORTING: BIRMINGHAM CITY COUNCIL HIGH COURT INJUNCTION
Birmingham City Council has launched High Court proceedings to secure an injunction against key figures in the "Raise the Colours" movement, seeking enhanced legal powers to deter the unauthorised display of flags on public infrastructure across the city.
The local authority has acted following a year of escalating complaints regarding alleged harassment, intimidation, and anti-social behavior linked to the widespread placing of Union and St George's Cross flags on council-owned street furniture, lampposts, and highway bridges. The council alleges the actions, framed by organisers as a patriotic campaign launched as a reaction to the government handling of illegal immigration, go beyond issues of highway inconvenience or safety issues and are affecting community cohesion and the rights of ordinary residents.
Presiding over the application at Birmingham Civil Justice Centre on Bull Street, High Court Judge Emma Kelly is considering whether to grant interim injunctive relief—potentially backed by powers of arrest—to restrict illegal flagging operations pending a full trial.
- Hearing Location: Court 205, Birmingham Civil Justice Centre, Bull Street
- Presiding Judge: High Court Judge Emma Kelly
- Applicant: Birmingham City Council (represented by Jonathan Manning)
- Primary Defendants: Ryan Bridge, Billy Allison, Ben Cullen and 'Persons Unknown‘, including the ‘Birmingham Five’ representing minority communities.
- Core Legal Issues: S.132 Highways Act 1980 (unauthorized attachments), public nuisance, proportionality of injunctive relief, and Articles 10 & 11 ECHR rights (freedom of expression and assembly)
LIVE REPORTING ⬇️
🔴 16:05
HIGH COURT HEARING TO RESUME IN NOVEMBER
Judge Emma Kelly adjourned proceedings until 10.30am on Monday, November 2, when the defence will have the opportunity to make its submissions before the court considers the council’s application further ⬇️
🔴 15:50
THE CHALLENGES AHEAD
The council’s case has now been heard. The defendants’ substantive arguments have not. Ryan Bridge has representation from barrister Dr Liam Wells, while 5 representatives of the “Persons Unknown” category have been permitted to make representations ⬇️
🔴 15:23
JUDGE QUESTIONS POWER OF ARREST
Judge Kelly noted that an Oxfordshire injunction against flagging did not seek a power of arrest against “Persons Unknown”. Manning said Birmingham’s evidence of harassment and distress showed a more serious situation ⬇️
🔴 15:15
JUDGE QUESTIONS PROPORTIONALITY
Judge Kelly earlier questioned whether full consideration had been given to ensuring the proposed injunction was the least restrictive measure capable of achieving the council’s aim, referring to the Supreme Court’s guidance in Ziegler ⬇️
🔴 15:10
JUDGE QUESTIONS EVIDENCE FROM OUTSIDE BIRMINGHAM
Judge Kelly earlier questioned the council over evidence presented to the court which did not relate to Birmingham. Manning accepted the point, but said it illustrated the type of activity occurring in the city ⬇️
🔴 15:05
DEFENCE WARNS OVER REVISED COUNCIL ORDER
Dr Liam Wells warned substantial changes could prejudice Ryan Bridge, who had paid for representation based on the existing filing. Manning said revisions would only clarify definitions, not alter the council’s case ⬇️
🔴 15:00
JUDGE TELLS COUNCIL TO TIGHTEN INJUNCTION WORDING
Judge Kelly told Manning he needed to tighten the wording of the proposed injunction after questioning the council over terms including “highway” and “highway fixture”. Manning agreed he would revise the definitions ⬇️
🔴 14:55
COUNCIL CLARIFIES PARKS WOULD NOT CURRENTLY BE COVERED
Manning told the court the injunction would not apply to flags attached to lamp posts in parks, as this had not been identified as a problem. He said the council could seek further remedies if that changed ⬇️
🔴 14:50
COUNCIL PRESSED ON SCOPE OF “HIGHWAY”
Manning was questioned about whether grass verges, roundabouts and trees would fall within the proposed restrictions. He suggested “highway” would include carriageways and walkways, but could not provide the court with a final definition ⬇️
🔴 14:45
JUDGE QUESTIONS MEANING OF “HIGHWAY FIXTURE”
Judge Kelly questioned whether people could fairly comply with the proposed injunction if its terminology was not sufficiently clear. Manning was unable to give a final definition of a “highway fixture” when pressed by the judge ⬇️
🔴 15:13
COUNCIL CONCLUDES THREE-HOUR CASE
Mr Manning summed up by citing threats and harassment. After nearly three hours of council evidence, it looks increasingly unlikely that Ryan Bridge and other defendants will be fully heard today ⬇️
🔴 14:44
“GOVERNMENT IS RUNNING SCARED”
Livestreams were played showing Bridge asking followers for funding to fight the case. In one video, he tells his audience that the government is running scared from their movement ⬇️
🔴 15:05
JUDGE PRESSES COUNCIL TO CONCLUDE
Judge Kelly urged Mr Manning to move to legal arguments, expressing concern the case won’t conclude today. The council outlined claims that a power of arrest clause is strictly necessary ⬇️
🔴 14:40
VIDEO EVIDENCE PLAYED IN COURT
The council played footage of Bridge blocking a road with a Stop sign while flags were put up. Another video showed him insisting to a resident that flags would go up regardless ⬇️
🔴 14:27
HATEFUL ABUSE DIRECTED AT COUNCILLORS
The court hears that councillors speaking out against the flags have received shocking messages. Meanwhile, Mr Manning highlighted threats, abuse and baseless slurs labelling individuals as ‘paedophiles’ for opposing flags ⬇️
🔴 14:10
PROCEEDINGS RESUME
The hearing has resumed in court room 205. The council advised the judge that defendant Ben Cullen confirmed he was aware of the hearing but had no intention of taking part in the case ⬇️
🔴 13:30
CASE INSIGHT: CRITICISM OF COUNCIL PRIORITIES
The injunction has also faced criticism outside court over Birmingham City Council’s priorities in pursuing the case, including from Cllr Jex Parkin @JexParkin, who has questioned whether the flag ban should be a priority for the city ⬇️
🔴 13:25
BIRMINGHAM FIVE COULD DERAIL INJUNCTION
The Birmingham Five’s legal arguments strike at the foundations of the council’s proposed order. Disadvantage one group — whether Patriots or gay-rights — and Human Rights issues arise; include everyone and the same challenge remains ⬇️
🔴 13:22
“PERSONS UNKNOWN” CHALLENGE COUNCIL ORDER
The five representatives argue the restrictions are disproportionate and could catch peaceful residents. They ask the court to exclude “Persons Unknown” from the order ⬇️
🔴 13:20
FIVE LGBTQ+ ADVOCATES CHALLENGE “PERSONS UNKNOWN”
Five Birmingham residents who celebrate historic gay-rights have stepped forward from the “Persons Unknown” category. They say the proposed order could also restrict peaceful Pride and minority rights flag displays ⬇️
🔴 13:18
CASE INSIGHT: COURT WILL HEAR FROM 8TH DEFENDANT
We have previously reported the position statement by 5 members of the LGBTQ+ community who stand up for free expression and historic minority rights. An admin error resulted in their filing not reaching the judge until now ⬇️
🔴 13:15
BRIDGE SAYS COUNCIL’S CASE IS OVERBROAD
Bridge’s written representations also challenge the council’s approach to the proceedings, including its handling of notice, service and the proposed restrictions. His defence will now be heard at the November hearing ⬇️
🔴 13:12
BRIDGE CHALLENGES COUNCIL’S CASE
Bridge’s position argues the council has not established the legal threshold for an interim injunction and says the proposed order would interfere disproportionately with his rights under Articles 10 and 11 of the ECHR ⬇️
🔴 13:10
CASE INSIGHT: COUNCIL ACCUSED OF ERRORS
Bridge alleges a “catalogue of errors” by the council, including failing to notify residents of the injunction and failing to provide a coherent case to justify the urgent High Court action ⬇️
🔴 13:08
“ATTEMPT TO SILENCE ME”
Bridge’s statement claims the council is using draconian methods to silence legitimate political opinions. He argues the application is an improper attempt to push a pointed political agenda ⬇️
🔴 13:07
RYAN BRIDGE NOW PREPARED TO FIGHT BACK
In the final days before the hearing, Bridge served a new witness statement to the council and court, fiercely rebutting the claims. He asserts his right to freely express his political views by publicly displaying the national flag ⬇️
🔴 13:06
COURT ADJOURNS FOR LUNCH
The case has paused for lunch. The council expects to conclude its arguments in 40 minutes, after which the court will hear from Bridge and anyone else wishing to make representations ⬇️
🔴 12:59
CLAIMED SERIOUS IMPACT TO COMMUNITY SAFETY
The council asserts the flagging has severely impacted the city. Police officers, councillors and an MP all reported threats to safety, leading to a drain on police and council resources ⬇️
🔴 12:53
FEAR AND DISTRESS IN THE COMMUNITY
Mr Manning read statements from residents of various ethnicities and faiths who reported feeling nervous. Locals claimed they were filmed by flaggers, causing fear and distress ⬇️
🔴 12:45
MP AND COUNCILLORS’ TESTIMONY
The council highlight reports of harassment experienced by locals. MP Al Carns reported over 120 constituent complaints, while Cllr Knowles referenced a Stirchley incident resulting in a broken leg ⬇️
🔴 12:29
BAN APPLIES TO ALL FLAGS
The council stressed it is not taking a partisan position. Manning clarified the injunction seeks to prohibit all unauthorised attachments, including Palestinian or LGBTQ+ flags on street furniture ⬇️
🔴 12:24
AGGRESSIVE AND DANGEROUS BEHAVIOUR ALLEGED
The council’s Director of Community Safety states flaggers have harassed residents and contractors day and night. The behaviour is described in written evidence as anti-social and dangerous ⬇️
🔴 12:15
PATTERN OF INTIMIDATION CLAIMED
Representing Birmingham City Council, Jonathan Manning outlines a 12-month pattern of alleged incidents involving abuse. He cites Cllr Izzy Knowles feeling intimidated after being surrounded by flaggers during an incident in Moseley ⬇️
🔴 11:45
THREE NAMED DEFENDANTS REMAIN
Judge Kelly confirms the council’s case is now proceeding against only three named individuals: Ryan Bridge, Billy Allison and Ben Cullen, in addition to ‘persons unknown’ ⬇️
🔴 11:27
FRUSTRATION OVER PAPERWORK
Judge Kelly had expressed frustration over how the council served papers. The council confirmed defendant Ben Cullen was served but told them in a phone call he had no interest in participating ⬇️
🔴 11:18
JUDGE EXPLAINS UNDERTAKINGS
The judge warns that signing the undertaking means committing not to put up flags without authority or harass contractors. Flouting this order could lead to severe consequences including fines ⬇️
🔴 11:08
COUNCIL OPENS ITS CASE
Council representative Jonathan Manning confirms named defendants Julian Keane, Elliot Stanley, Mark Keating and Ross Child have offered legal undertakings. The council has accepted these ⬇️
🔴 11:03
SUPPORTERS PACK PUBLIC GALLERY
Judge Emma Kelly has taken her seat in court 205. Following the arrival of a contingent of 20+ Raise the Colours supporters, an overflow room with a live video link is set up to accommodate members of the public unable to get a seat ⬇️
🔴 09:42
“WE ARE LOSING OUR IDENTITY”
Speaking outside court, Bridge claimed Raise the Colours is not racist, has many British Asian supporters, and he would never tear down LGBTQ+ flags. He said the movement is about national pride and opposing illegal migration ⬇️
🔴 09:12
FLAGGING SUPPORTERS CALLED TO BULL STREET
Ryan Bridge, primary defendant and co-founder of Raise the Colours, has called for supporters to turn up at court today. Supporters have donated to help fund his legal representation ⬇️
🔴 09:19
EMERGENCY INJUNCTION HEARING
Birmingham City Council is pursuing an emergency injunction to stop Ryan Bridge and others from placing flags on lampposts and bridges. The hearing is before High Court Judge Emma Kelly ⬇️
🔴 09:00
LIVE: BIRMINGHAM COUNCIL IN HIGH COURT FLAG BAN BID
Birmingham City Council is in the High Court seeking an emergency injunction against “Raise the Colours” and UNKNOWN!
The reporter
Jason KingCourt Correspondent and Birmingham Desk Lead




